The members of the Baseball Writers Association of America, who were involved in the voting, also recognized Ryan Howard, the defending MVP with a fifth place finish in the balloting. Howard didn't collect any first or second place votes, put finished with a total of 112 points. Chase Utley was eighth in the balloting, giving the Phillies three players in the top eight, while no other team had more than one in that group. Aaron Rowand picked up three points, putting him in a tie for 22nd in the voting. The Mets David Wright finished fourth.
Rollins admitted to having some nerves as he waited for the call to confirm his win. "When the call finally came, it was a great thing. I was thinking not to think about it, but you can't help but think about it in a situation like this," said Rollins. One of his first calls was to Holliday, to congratulate him on having a great season.